Recruitment Discrimination by Geographic Origin: Case No. 185
Guiding case · final appellate judgment
Reported facts
In July 2019 Yan Jialin applied via Zhaopin for “legal specialist” and “assistant to the chair” roles at Zhejiang Sheraton Resort Co. Her CV listed household registration in Nanyang, Henan, and residence in Hangzhou. Notarised platform records show both applications were viewed on 4 July 2019 at 14:28 and marked unsuitable with the reason “Henanese” within about one minute. She spent RMB 1,000 on notarisation and sued in the Hangzhou Internet Court for apology, emotional-harm damages and costs.
Published outcome
The Hangzhou Internet Court ordered oral and published apology plus RMB 10,000 for emotional harm and reasonable rights-enforcement costs (2019 Zhe 0192 Min Chu 6405). Both sides appealed; the Hangzhou Intermediate People’s Court dismissed the appeals and upheld the judgment on 15 May 2020 ((2020) Zhe 01 Min Zhong 736).
What mattered in this case
The dispute was whether naming ‘Henanese’ as the rejection reason on a recruitment platform, with no shown link to the advertised duties, infringed equal employment rights. Platform screenshots notarised by the Hangzhou Internet Notary Office recorded that both applications were viewed and rejected within one minute for that reason; the employer did not prove a legitimate job-related need. Procedure ran from a civil equal-employment claim in the Hangzhou Internet Court through an appeal that upheld apology and RMB 10,000 covering emotional harm and reasonable enforcement costs (including RMB 1,000 notarisation). A common misread is that any unexplained rejection equals discrimination: this case turned on an explicit origin-based reason plus preserved platform evidence, not on silence alone.
Limits when comparing your own situation
Rejection alone is not proof of discrimination. This guiding case turned on an explicit geographic-origin reason, notarised platform evidence, and a civil equal-employment claim. Another hiring decision without that wording, or a different procedure, needs its own facts and route.
Use the case to organise your next step
Save the vacancy requirements, complete rejection message and platform dates before access disappears. Separate an explicit reference to origin from your guess about why an application failed. Ask how the stated factor relates to the work requirements. Keep the record unaltered and obtain advice about the appropriate equal-employment route; this judgment’s remedy is not a standard payout for every rejection.
Documents to gather
- The vacancy text for each role and the date you applied.
- Unaltered rejection messages or platform records showing the stated reason and timestamps.
- Notarisation or other lawful preservation of the platform pages before access disappears.
- Any employer reply explaining how the stated factor relates to the duties.
Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.
References and editorial date
Supreme People’s Court
Source publication:2022-07-06
Source checked and summary prepared:2026-11-05
Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.
Supreme People’s Court · 最高人民法院https://www.court.gov.cn/shenpan/xiangqing/364691.html