Revoked Job Offer After Resigning: Zhang's Reliance Loss Award
Official typical-case report · judgment outcome
Reported facts
Zhang worked for a talent-service company and planned to move to a technology firm. After talks, he received an emailed offer naming him finance manager with stated pay and a reporting date, requiring a leaving certificate and stating the offer would take effect after his signature and company confirmation. He replied “received”, resigned the next day and completed leaving formalities. The technology firm then cancelled recruitment, citing financial problems. Zhang sued for RMB 60,000, alleging breach of good faith and contracting negligence.
Published outcome
The court held that workers are relatively vulnerable when contracting, that Zhang reasonably believed employment would follow from the offer and communications, and that cancelling without proper cause breached the employer’s good-faith contracting duty. Weighing prior income, a reasonable job-search period and the employer’s fault, it awarded RMB 20,000. The individual judgment date and court locality are not disclosed in the typical-case report.
What mattered in this case
The reported typical case concerns pre-contractual good faith, not a dismissal after employment began. Zhang received an emailed offer for a finance-manager role stating pay and a start date, requiring a leaving certificate from his prior employer and saying the offer would take effect after his signature and the company’s confirmation. He replied “received”, resigned the next day, then was told recruitment was cancelled because of the new employer’s financial problems. He claimed RMB 60,000 for contracting negligence; the court found he reasonably relied on the offer, that cancelling without proper cause breached good-faith contracting duties, and—weighing prior income, a reasonable period to find other work and the employer’s fault—awarded RMB 20,000. Misconception: every withdrawn offer equals the same damages, or that this report substitutes for an unfair-dismissal claim once work has started.
Limits when comparing your own situation
An offer dispute before employment begins is not automatically a dismissal claim. The reported result depended on reliance after a detailed offer and on the court’s assessment of loss factors; the report does not invent trial transcripts beyond those elements. Not every withdrawn offer produces the same remedy or amount.
Use the case to organise your next step
Keep the full offer, conditions, acceptance, start date and cancellation message. Link any resignation or expense to the communication that prompted it, with dates and receipts. Record efforts to find replacement work rather than treating all future lost salary as established loss. Ask an adviser which pre-employment claim and procedure fit the facts; a promised job and an employment relationship already begun are different situations.
Documents to gather
- The full offer email or letter, including conditions, pay, start date and effectiveness wording.
- Your acceptance or ‘received’ reply and the resignation/leaving proof from the prior employer.
- The cancellation message and any stated reason, with dates.
- Evidence of prior income and of efforts to find replacement work after cancellation.
Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.
References and editorial date
Supreme People’s Court · typical civil case
Source publication:2025-12-16
Source checked and summary prepared:2026-11-05
Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.
Supreme People’s Court · 最高人民法院https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/484101.html