Discriminatory Supervisor Job Reference: Thomasina B. Appeal
Administrative appeal decision · reversed and remanded
Reported facts
A supervisor’s negative reference led to rejection for another federal job, despite favourable evaluations. EEOC found the explanation inconsistent and unsupported, and discrimination played a role.
Published outcome
EEOC reversed the agency’s no-discrimination finding, ordered another official to give future references, and required further investigation of damages. It did not set a final damages figure.
What mattered in this case
The EEOC compared the negative reference with favourable evaluations and found the explanation inconsistent and unsupported. Its appeal decision required a different official for future references and further damages investigation; it did not fix final damages. Compare the reference, evaluations and selection decision separately.
Limits when comparing your own situation
The applicant was still employed; this is included for reference-related job transitions. Federal administrative procedures are distinct from private-sector claims and other countries’ rules.
Use the case to organise your next step
Identify whether you have the actual reference or only an account of it from the recruiting employer. Keep those sources distinct and compare with existing evaluations and the rejection explanation. Request a factual correction through an appropriate channel without publishing allegations about the referee. If you are a federal employee, check the federal EEO process promptly instead of applying a private-sector procedure.
Questions to prepare for your own situation
- Do I know who supplied the reference and its exact contents?
- How does it compare with existing performance records?
- What evidence links the reference to the lost opportunity?
Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.
References and editorial date
EEOC Office of Federal Operations
Decision date:2019-02-27
Source checked and summary prepared:2026-10-04
Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commissionhttps://www.eeoc.gov/sites/default/files/migrated_files/decisions/0120173008.pdf