HR demands one particular I-9 document: can I choose acceptable documents?
Understand document choice and distinguish identity verification from discriminatory extra demands.
Reading body prepared：4 October 2026
Content review lead：Lemon
Who chooses the I-9 documents?
Under U.S. Department of Justice guidance, the worker—not the employer—chooses which acceptable documents to present for Form I-9. You may present one document from List A (which proves both identity and work authorization) or a combination of one document from List B (identity) and one from List C (work authorization). The employer may not demand a specific document or require extra documents based on your citizenship status or national origin. This rule does not mean a document that is unacceptable under the current rules must be accepted, and it does not determine your immigration status.
How to prepare before the verification
Ask the employer for the current official Form I-9 instructions and the list of acceptable documents. Review the list and identify which combination you can actually provide. Keep a record of the request and the date of the onboarding process. Do not send original identity documents to a recruiter who cannot establish that they are an authorized employer representative. A request to verify employment eligibility is different from demanding a specific immigration document merely because of your name or appearance.
What to do if a document is rejected
If the employer rejects a document you presented, ask for the specific reason and which instruction or rule applies. The problem may be identity, expiry, or the document category—do not guess. Record what you presented and the employer's response, but do not share your document numbers publicly. If a receipt or extension might be relevant, consult current guidance on that specific document type; do not assume that any application receipt works for every I-9 requirement.
When the demand may be discriminatory
Discrimination occurs when the employer demands a specific document or extra documents because of your citizenship status or national origin. For example, if you present a valid List A document and the employer insists on a green card or a specific visa document, that may be a discriminatory demand. However, the employer may still reject a document that is unacceptable under the current rules or does not match your identity. The key is the reason for the demand—ask the employer to state it in writing if possible.
Hypothetical example: a valid passport vs. a green card demand
Suppose a worker presents a valid, unexpired U.S. passport (a List A document) during onboarding. The employer says, "We only accept green cards or employment authorization documents." The worker asks, "My passport is on the acceptable List A—why is it not sufficient?" The employer replies, "We prefer a different document." In this situation, the worker should ask for the specific rule that excludes a valid passport. If the employer cannot cite a valid reason, the demand may be discriminatory. The worker can then consider filing a discrimination complaint with the IER. This example is illustrative; it does not predict the outcome of any actual case.
How to ask the right questions
When discussing I-9 documents with an employer, use specific questions such as: "Which list and item number does my document fall under?" "What is the specific reason my document is not acceptable?" "Can you provide the official instruction that requires a different document?" These questions help identify whether the issue is a legitimate verification requirement or a discriminatory demand. Avoid vague questions like "Why are you doing this?" which may not elicit a useful response.
Next steps if the issue is unresolved
If the employer does not provide a valid reason and you believe the demand is discriminatory, you can contact the U.S. Department of Justice's Immigrant and Employee Rights Section (IER) for assistance. IER handles discrimination complaints related to the employment eligibility verification process. Before contacting them, prepare a clear summary of the demand, the documents you offered, and the employer's stated reason. If your concern is about your immigration status or work authorization itself, you may need to consult a qualified immigration adviser. This article does not instruct you to use a document you are not entitled to hold, nor does it guarantee that you can start work.
Need to take the next step?
References
U.S. Department of Justice · IER Form I-9 guidance
This is our independently written reading guide. Reference details are recorded below.
https://www.justice.gov/crt/form-i-9-and-e-verify