Year-End Bonus After Restructuring Dismissal: Guiding Case 183
Guiding case · final appellate judgment
Reported facts
Fang Yue joined MetLife (Sino-US United Tai) and last contracted as senior strategy manager for 1 July 2015–30 June 2017. In October 2017 the company abolished the strategy department; after nearly two months of failed change talks it issued a 29 December 2017 termination notice citing major change in objective circumstances. The employee handbook said year-end bonus depended on company policy, performance and hire before 1 October that year, and that leaving in or before the payment month (around March the next year) barred payment. Fang also claimed double wages for an unsigned period; that item is separate from the bonus dispute.
Published outcome
Huangpu District Court ordered RMB 192,500 double-wage differential for August–December 2017 but refused the 2017 bonus ((2018) Hu 0101 Min Chu 10726). On 4 March 2019 Shanghai No. 2 Intermediate People’s Court upheld the double-wage item, set aside the bonus refusal and ordered RMB 138,600 gross 2017 year-end bonus ((2018) Hu 02 Min Zhong 11292), finding a full year’s work through 29 December and no proof of deficient performance.
What mattered in this case
The appellate issue was whether a handbook rule denying year-end bonus if the worker left in or before the payment month could defeat a claim after an Article 40-style dismissal for major organisational change. Fang Yue’s strategy role was abolished in an October 2017 restructure; after failed consultation she was dismissed on 29 December 2017. The handbook required hire before 1 October of the bonus year and barred payment if departure occurred in or before the (usually March) payment month. First instance refused the 2017 bonus; the Shanghai No. 2 Intermediate People’s Court held that, with no mandatory statute on bonus design, rules must still be fair: she worked through 29 December (the year’s last two days being a weekend), completing a full year’s work, and the employer did not prove deficient performance—so the pre-payment-month departure bar was unreasonable and RMB 138,600 gross was awarded. Misconception: any resignation before the bonus month automatically forfeits the award even when departure was employer-driven reorganisation.
Limits when comparing your own situation
The worker did not voluntarily resign; departure followed organisational change under the reported Article 40 pathway. Bonus terms, performance evidence and departure circumstances all mattered. The guiding case does not guarantee every former employee a year-end bonus, especially after an ordinary voluntary resignation before the payment month.
Use the case to organise your next step
List the bonus rule that applied in the earning year, the restructuring timeline and the exact termination ground. Separate voluntary resignation from employer-driven departure. Ask whether performance criteria were communicated and whether the employer can show you failed them. A handbook bar tied only to leaving before the payment month needs checking against the reason you left; this award is not a promise that every former employee receives a year-end bonus.
Documents to gather
- The bonus rules or handbook clauses for the earning year, including payment-month wording.
- Restructuring notices, consultation records and the termination letter with its legal basis.
- Evidence of work completed that year and any performance assessments the employer relies on.
- Pay records showing how prior bonuses were calculated, if available.
Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.
References and editorial date
Supreme People’s Court
Source publication:2022-07-04
Source checked and summary prepared:2026-11-05
Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.
Supreme People’s Court · 最高人民法院https://www.court.gov.cn/shenpan/xiangqing/364671.html