Probation Dismissal & Pay in Lieu: Verton Tribunal Ruling
Tribunal decision · strike out; costs application refused
Reported facts
Ms U Verton worked for Trenitalia C2C Ltd from 1 June to 1 October 2020—four months of a six-month probation—and was dismissed with one month’s pay in lieu for unsatisfactory performance. She did not claim unfair dismissal (under two years’ service). Her claim form and statement alleged that the dismissal was procedurally unfair and contrary to the ACAS Code; the tribunal treated the nearest characterisation as wrongful dismissal. Contract clause 2.5 allowed one month’s notice in probation (three months after); clause 7.2.1 provided PILON; clause 15.1 said disciplinary procedures did not form part of the contract.
Published outcome
On 18 August 2021 Employment Judge Burns struck out the claim as having no reasonable prospect of success: dismissal matched the probation notice/PILON terms, and unfair-procedure points could not found wrongful dismissal once notice pay was paid. The respondent’s £10,211 costs application was refused despite prior warnings, citing good-faith reliance on CAB advice and likely undue hardship.
What mattered in this case
Employment Judge Burns struck out Ms Verton’s claim after a tribunal-listed hearing on 18 August 2021 (2200376/2021). She had four months of a six-month probation at Trenitalia c2c, was dismissed for unsatisfactory performance with one month’s pay in lieu, and—having under two years’ service—did not bring unfair dismissal. Her ET1 and statement alleged procedural unfairness and ACAS Code breaches; taken at their highest, the closest claim was wrongful dismissal. The contract allowed one month’s notice (or PILON) in probation and stated disciplinary procedures were not contractual. Wrongful dismissal asks only whether the contract was breached; pay already matched notice, so unfair-procedure arguments could not rescue the claim. Costs of £10,211 were refused despite warnings, because she acted in good faith after CAB advice and enforcement would likely cause undue hardship. Misconception: ACAS Code breaches alone create a freestanding tribunal claim during probation when notice was paid.
Limits when comparing your own situation
This is a 2021 first-instance decision about its contract and pleaded claim. It does not mean people on probation have no rights. Discrimination, whistleblowing or unpaid-wage claims are different causes of action with their own tests. Do not treat historical two-year unfair-dismissal service rules or this strike-out as advice on your current eligibility—check Acas and current law for your decision date.
Use the case to organise your next step
Compare the probation notice clause, the termination letter and the payment covering notice. Read separately whether the handbook procedure was incorporated into the contract. If you received one month’s pay, that answers an amount question but does not automatically answer a separate discrimination or earned-wage issue. Ask an adviser to identify the actual claim and current deadline before using this historical strike-out decision as a comparison.
Documents to gather
- The probation and notice clauses, including any PILON wording.
- The termination letter, stated reason and proof of notice pay received.
- Handbook or disciplinary procedure text and whether it is incorporated into the contract.
- Any Acas or adviser notes identifying which claim type and deadline apply now.
Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.
References and editorial date
Employment Tribunal · published by HM Courts & Tribunals Service
Source publication:2021-08-27
Source checked and summary prepared:2026-11-05
Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.
UK Governmenthttps://www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions/ms-u-verton-v-trenitalia-c2c-ltd-2200376-slash-2021
UK Governmenthttps://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6127a06dd3bf7f63a65bde71/Ms_U_Verton__vs_Trenitalia_C2C_Ltd_.pdf