Adding New Dismissal Reasons in Court: Guiding Case No. 180
Guiding case · final appellate judgment
Reported facts
Sun Xianfeng’s labour contract with Huai’an West District HR Development Co. ran from 1 July 2016. After prior disciplinary deductions for uniform, proxy clocking and platform insults, the operations unit told him on 17 October 2017 to stop work over remittance issues; the next day his card would not register. A 25 October leaving certificate and a 30 October termination notice alleged unexcused absence of three or more days from 20 October. In court the company also relied on the earlier misconduct not listed in that notice.
Published outcome
Guannan County People’s Court ordered RMB 18,989.46 compensation for unlawful dismissal ((2018) Su 0724 Min Chu 2732). On 22 April 2019 the Lianyungang Intermediate People’s Court dismissed the employer’s appeal and upheld the judgment ((2019) Su 07 Min Zhong 658), reviewing the notice’s stated absence ground and rejecting later add-on reasons.
What mattered in this case
The live issue was the legality of dismissal for alleged absence of three or more days as stated in the 30 October 2017 termination notice—not every later misconduct allegation. After Sun was told to stop work on 17 October and could not clock in the next day, the company later cited absence from 20 October; it failed to prove notice to return or signed attendance proving that absence. In litigation it also raised unpaid remittances, uniform breaches, proxy clocking and platform insults that were known earlier but were not grounds in the notice and had been met with a proposed reassignment rather than dismissal. The appeal limited review to the notice’s stated ground, refused to enlarge the case with those add-ons, and upheld unlawful-dismissal compensation of RMB 18,989.46. Misconception: prior discipline points automatically salvage a later notice that rests on unproven absence.
Limits when comparing your own situation
This does not excuse proven serious misconduct. The guiding holding limits review to the ground communicated when employment ended and to proof of that ground. Another notice that listed different facts, or a case where absence is proved, would be assessed on those materials.
Use the case to organise your next step
Preserve the first notice and the date you received it; keep later explanations as separate documents rather than replacing the original. If absence is alleged, keep attendance records and messages directing you not to work. Ask which facts support the stated reason. This lets an adviser compare the dismissal actually communicated with later arguments without assuming all misconduct allegations are irrelevant.
Documents to gather
- The first termination notice and the date and method of delivery.
- Messages or records directing you to stop work, and any failed clock-in evidence.
- Attendance sheets you signed or disputed, kept separately from later explanations.
- Any later letters that add new misconduct grounds not listed in the first notice.
Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.
References and editorial date
Supreme People’s Court
Source publication:2022-07-06
Source checked and summary prepared:2026-11-05
Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.
Supreme People’s Court · 最高人民法院https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/364641.html