← All cases
United States / Transfer & changes

Blanket Criminal Background Checks on Rehire: BMW Settlement

Consent-decree settlement

A settlement records agreed terms; it is not a judgment or arbitration finding that the allegations were proved.

Case scope:South Carolina · federal race-discrimination litigationConsent decree: 8 September 2015; screening occurred in 2008

Reported facts

After a logistics-contractor change, existing workers re-applied and underwent criminal screening. EEOC alleged the blanket exclusions disproportionately affected Black workers, without regard to record age or offence level.

Published outcome

The federal court entered a $1.6 million settlement decree, with employment opportunities, training and monitoring. The employer had changed its guidelines.

What mattered in this case

The contractor change explains why existing logistics workers faced a new screen while seeking to continue their work. EEOC challenged the effect of the conviction policy, including exclusions applied without distinguishing the age or level of the offence. The reported resolution combined money, employment opportunities and changes to screening practices. For a comparison, separate the policy used from the accuracy of an individual report and from the question of who made the employment decision. The settlement does not itself answer all three questions in another application.

Limits when comparing your own situation

The settlement did not prohibit every criminal check. Contractor changes, job requirements and the impact of a policy need separate assessment.

Use the case to organise your next step

First identify whether your employer changed or only the contractor supplying a service. Keep the re-application notice, screening criteria and any report you received. If information is wrong, identify the exact disputed entry; if the policy itself is the concern, record how it was applied to your application. Report accuracy, employment continuity and possible discriminatory effects are separate questions.

Documents to gather

  • The contractor-change announcement and instructions requiring existing workers to apply again.
  • Your earlier service records, the new application and the role description used for screening.
  • The screening policy or criteria supplied, the report received and the exact entry disputed, if any.
  • The decision notice and correspondence identifying the decision-maker and the explanation given.

Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.

References and editorial date

EEOC

Source publication:2015-09-08

Source checked and summary prepared:2026-10-04

Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.

Equal Employment Opportunity Commissionhttps://www.eeoc.gov/newsroom/bmw-pay-16-million-and-offer-jobs-settle-federal-race-discrimination-lawsuit

Report a correction →