Withholding Earned Project Bonus by Stalling Approval: Case 182
Guiding case · appellate judgment reversing dismissal of claim
Reported facts
Peng Yuxiang’s team introduced qualifying projects under a reward scheme. The company refused rewards on incomplete approval grounds and refused to restart the process.
Published outcome
The appeal court awarded RMB 1,259,564.40. Unjustified refusal to perform approval obligations could not block rewards whose substantive conditions had been met.
What mattered in this case
The court examined the reward conditions separately from the company’s approval process. The projects met the scheme’s conditions, while the company did not substantiate its objections about losses, misconduct or earlier rewards. It also refused to resume approval. The amount still depended on the scheme and the allocation of the team reward. When comparing documents, identify evidence of qualifying work, the reason approval stopped and the calculation of the individual share as three separate issues.
Limits when comparing your own situation
This was not a ruling that any expected bonus is payable. The reward scheme, qualifying work, allocation and objections were assessed.
Use the case to organise your next step
Separate the reward’s substantive conditions from the approval steps. Keep the scheme, evidence of qualifying work, submission and the reason approval stopped. Request a response identifying the unmet condition rather than just an “approval pending” label. An expected amount still needs a calculation and allocation basis; this case does not turn every unfinished application into an earned reward.
Documents to gather
- The reward scheme in force for the projects, including eligibility, calculation and approval terms.
- Project records and submitted reward applications, with any acknowledgements or approval history.
- The team allocation record and a calculation connecting the total reward to your claimed share.
- Written reasons for refusal and records addressing any alleged losses, misconduct or earlier payment.
Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.
References and editorial date
Supreme People’s Court
Source publication:2022-07-06
Source checked and summary prepared:2026-10-04
Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.
Supreme People’s Court · 最高人民法院https://www.court.gov.cn/shenpan/xiangqing/364661.html