← All cases
Australia / Transfer & changes

Individual Flexibility Agreements Underpaying Staff: Goodwin

Enforceable undertaking · completed back-pay reported

Case scope:Australia · ACT and New South Wales · aged careUndertaking announcement: 22 September 2026

Reported facts

An audit found 313 workers’ individual flexibility arrangements failed the better-off-overall test, relying too much on non-cash benefits. Payroll configuration also missed shift penalties for 22 others.

Published outcome

Goodwin signed an enforceable undertaking after completing over $1.39 million in back-pay, interest and superannuation for 335 workers.

What mattered in this case

Prepare two checks rather than one combined headline figure. First compare the signed flexibility arrangement with the underlying pay terms for the same roster, showing cash payments and non-cash benefits separately. Then check whether payroll actually applied the shift payments recorded in the relevant terms. For each difference, ask which hours, rates and benefits were used and how the correction was calculated. Keeping the arrangement comparison separate from payroll implementation makes it easier to identify what remains unanswered after a back-payment.

Limits when comparing your own situation

An enforceable undertaking is a regulatory commitment, not a damages judgment. The comparison depends on the applicable award or agreement and the actual arrangement.

Use the case to organise your next step

Compare a representative roster under the original award or agreement with the proposed flexible arrangement. Separate ordinary pay, penalties, allowances and non-cash benefits rather than comparing only headline totals. Ask how the better-off comparison was made for your circumstances and keep the signed version. An arrangement being convenient does not answer whether its pay conditions satisfy the applicable rules.

Documents to gather

  • The signed flexibility arrangement and the award or agreement terms it was compared against.
  • The employer’s comparison worksheet, listing cash rates, penalties, allowances and non-cash benefits separately.
  • Rosters and payslips for matching periods, with the shift types and hours clearly marked.
  • Correction notices and payment records separating back-pay, interest and superannuation.

Next steps and questions are our guidance, not findings in the case.

References and editorial date

Fair Work Ombudsman

Source publication:2026-09-22

Source checked and summary prepared:2026-10-04

Our concise paraphrase is not an official translation or an assessment of your case. Reference addresses are recorded for traceability.

Fair Work Ombudsmanhttps://www.fairwork.gov.au/newsroom/media-releases/2026-media-releases/september-2026/20260922-goodwin-aged-care-eu-media-release

legislation.gov.auhttps://www.legislation.gov.au/C2009A00028/2026-07-07/2026-07-07/text/original/epub/OEBPS/document_1/document_1.html#_Toc236384485

Report a correction →